Showing posts with label Research Methods and Dissertation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Research Methods and Dissertation. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 November 2012

"May All your Bacon Burn" Looking For Case Studys

Identifying Movies for Case study 


 
"Howls Moving Castle" By Studio Ghibli
  
Over Saturday and this morning I decided to take a look at movies discussed at my meeting with Lynn, The purpose of this was to Identify movies that could be good case studies coming from different studios and possibly cultural backgrounds. While watching these movies I took notes on areas that stood out toward my observations while also trying to relate it What I believed to my critical framework. However, Throughout all these moves instead of watching for particular things such as Gestures and Body Pose.  What I was paying attention was Honesty of Character, Consistency,  Character Rhythm Actions and Reactions.  I feel that Honesty And Consistency was the attributes i noticed most. To summarize what I mean about this is: when are first introduced to the character we automatically start to judge the type of person that character is. Honesty and consistency are if the character is acting on their own thoughts or demonstrating themselves coming to their own conclusion and then acting on that conclusion while also staying true to the character that we were first introduced too.  
"Howls Moving Castle" By Studio Ghibli

Howls Moving Castle
Sophie At the beginning of the movie seemed to be a more distant character one that would do allot of thinking without verbalizing those thoughts. However, After she was curse she became a more expressive character with these traits Calm, Humorous, Cunning, Practical, Fearless, Curious, Positive. This was consistent in her character throughout the rest of the movie and the only moment these were broken was the moment of sadness after feeling she might have killed Karushifa and Howl. These also carried out through her transformations but these change in age also changed he body posture and walking styles. Even while Old she still exerted the same energy from her character as if she was young.
One thing that was noticed within the character of this film was how things would not always be directly consistent but this was sometimes related to visual design over the performance. The walk & Running cycles stood out the most in this film as the characters often performed these actions the same way and also in movies in previous films. This makes the run cycle of Studio Ghibli seem more like a signature run to the studio.
Sophie Was probably the only character within the movies I managed to clearly identify her characters traits. Which may be because Howls Moving Castle was the final movie I watched before now.
"Over The Hedge" By DreamWorks

Over the Hedge
RJS Actions were constantly consistent  with how he was establish it reached a point when he could not be evaluated regularly but only to key points in the story or during the revelation of his character arc.  RJ also had the most identifiable Psychological gestures out of the four films they made it clear when RJ was at a conflict with himself in his mind along with conflicting his spoken words.
The overall character  was identified as an Opportunist Without luck on His side 2mins and 35 seconds into the movie and as said before he was consistent to this throughout the movie. Other than Psychological gestures the movie itself demonstrated Status exchange and Rhythm. Generally around the interaction of RJ and Verne the movie also made use of the Double Bounce in RJs Walk cycle.


"Belleville Rendez-vous" by Les Armateurs
Belleville Rendezvous
Belleville Rendezvous is still very open there was barely anything I could take note of as I wasn't entirely sure how to interpret my framework to this movie. It did for a matter of fact stay Honest and Consistent to its characters. However, the characters movement and style of movement was very original to my own experience. This is particularly why  I struggled with this movie, The boy felt rather absent as his only actions were walking, clapping , looking, Cycling, Moping. Which was consistant throughout the whole movie, I did question whether he stuck to a strict schedule.
The older woman gave out more as the whistle blowing began to seem like it would defining her mind set and Rhythm. Comparing the earlier moments of the movie it done a great job of setting a scene for the later half for example: When she was chasing after the boy on a small bike while the larger boy was also on a larger bike. Later you see her in a Small Pedal boat chasing after a large steam boat and in my opinion it is a statement toward the woman's stamina and dedication to a task. There earlier scenes established her as a caring woman toward the boy and this continue throughout the film. 

"The Prince of Egypt" By DreamWorks
 The Prince of Egypt
Out of all the movies Moses was the most inconstant character, At the beginning of the movie he was established as a Free, Mischievous and "Doesn't care to much" character. However, Finding out he was not born of royal blood completely changed his character or mainly as his Values which throughout the movie didn't add up. The movie itself summarizes the issue itself when Aaron says  "In fact Moses.. When did you start caring about Slaves?...Was it when you found out you where One of us?" ................. Moses Says "I Did not See cause I did not wish to see"
I feel that this movie was particularly interesting as it broke more or less every part of my frame work I was looking into. It also reached the point on when I question Moses as an individual character with his own thoughts and personality and ended up classifying him as a puppet. The only time when I identified Honesty or Consistency from him was in the presence of his Brother Ramses in which he began to resume the traits he had from before.
The movie itself if it had been structured slightly differently has Amazing examples on how Moses values as a prince could have changed to value Slaves. This in my own opinion would make the Moses character Arc more believable and credible.  However the Issue that can be explored is whether or not "The Prince of Egypt" is considered a good movie despite the theory's that are being broken. If it is why is that ?, Is it Visual effects or possibly the age group its aimed at.


Conclusion
The Four movies have their own merits towards become case studies, This is because they all don't exactly line up toward my critical frame work but each contributes their own individual areas. I am looking for personality and how the character stays true to that personality by what mostly their body and eyes for thoughts. However that removes the voice from the character which is also a way to identify personality. Take Karushifa from "Howls Moving Castle" as an example he looks like a fire with two eyes and occasionally two hands and identifying his personality came from his actions and reactions through his voice.

Howls Moving castle After establishing the character traits of Sophie as an older woman stayed consistent to those traits a clear demonstration of Honesty in character. It in some sense broke that all character have their own Rhythm theory as it adopted the same Rhythm as other characters mainly in walking and running.

Over The Hedge had RJ a Consistent character through the whole film and it displayed a great deal of RJ inner conflicts through the use of psychological gestures. However, He was so consistent that identifying anymore of his personality  called for waiting until pinnacle moment of the story over the more subtle ones found in Sophie from Howls moving castle.

Belleville Rendezvous was also consistent however it felt unique and also relied more toward the subtext and context that the situation were happening in. The Woman having her own characterization of Fixing her glasses in a repetitive motion.  The earlier moment also justifying the later actions and possibility. 


The Prince of Egypt broke everything I was looking for as it didn't  have the same constancy, Anticipation or sense of personality as the other Three movies however the movie itself was still engaging the characters being somewhat likeable.  The main issue here is that This problem was only identified with Moses,  Tzipporah and Ramses were the complete opposite they proved the things I was looking for and even become great examples of it.


 After note 
There are still other movies such as Spirited away and Arthur and the Invisibles that i would like to take look at however Those can wait a few days as two days have already been spent investigating this area and i feel that i am beginning to Lack in the creation of my own materials, Areas i plan to focus on are my Story Beats and Test animations.

Friday, 23 November 2012

Supervisor Meeting, Lit Review, Methodology & Project Direction.



Meeting One with project supervisor - Lynn Parker.
I Had my first official meeting with my project supervisor Lynn Parker, The meeting agenda regarding:
1.      Literature Review Draft (Approached the correct way)
2.      Methodology  - Sketchbook,  Literature Theory's = Media tests  and Case study's ( Brave, Wall.E, Emperors New Grove.)
3.      Appropriate Approach for evaluation on the media tests ( External input over only Self-evaluation).
4.      Direction of the Project  ->  Lilly and Marys Story, Personality & History break down and converted into Media clips.

Literature Review
The main point that had been brought up in my Literature review feedback was to create links between the different topics addressed and how they relate to my aim. There was also a need of describing specialist terms as the proposal is aimed to be written so that someone that is not familiar with the topic can understand.

Methodology
We also discussed my methodology until recently I have struggled my establish a method of approaching this section. The combination of lecture sessions and group discussions had help to narrow down the approaches I was currently doing and the amount required from the project. I decided to discuss  the three methods I expected to be appropriate for my project, Along with how I should class the approach. Together we determined mixed methods as  I am concluding that my project fall onto Sketchbook work in order to explore visual representations. While deriving theory's and concepts from existing literature and then applying them both in my sketchbook as a planning tool while also applying them in practice in 3D.
 
Finally Case study's Examine existing films against my critical frame work which is backed by theory's from the existing literature. During the meeting I pointed toward Brave, Wall.e and the Emperors New Grove (Also Brother bear).  This was because each movie had contained either a Transformation of  how the character looks. However, the continued to act in the same manner as they did before. for example, Brother bear, Brave and Empeors new grove. Each movie has a character that is transformed into an animal however their thought process and acting continues to remain the same.

  Taking Wall.e as the other approach it focused on  limited dialogue so the majority of the commutation was taken by the body language, actions and reaction of the character. There was at least 3 characters that had aspects of the theory's I have currently read about. This brought in some advice from Lynn about focusing on only one of the characters. Currently at this time I am leaning towards Eve.
There was also an Issue that all the films I had suggested being from Disney or Pixar. This results in the study only focusing on a particularly approach by  a single studio. So I have been directed toward Dreamworks and Studio Ghibli's films. Something I practically liked about this is that it will factor in cross culture animation along with a difference in animation style However, I now have to identify movies that would be appropriate case studies from these studios.

Evaluation on the media tests
This point was not discussed in an in-depth as we began running short on time Lynn commented on evaluating it against my critical framework, However it was not appropriate to the meaning I had in mind.  

Direction of the Project 
The direction of my project was the final thing we discussed, For this I pitched a summary of the story I wish to tell involving Lilly and Mary. Along with the visual approach they will be displayed. Lynn  was able to identify it as a collage approach and suggested I study and take pointers from the beginning of Up. She initially liked the idea of the story but also pointed out two issue currently present which was to do with the scope of the project. Along with a gap in development of the character.  I could very much agree to this as I have been having issue with this very problem. At the early stages of this project I was able to conceptualize how Mary would move, act, react and her interests. While I struggled with the same area involving Lilly. On the other hand when it came to putting the story together I was able to create a purpose of Lilly needing Mary and how Lilly would progress throughout the story while struggling to decide how Mary would develop.
Lynn pointed out that I have Established why Lilly needs Mary but why does Mary need Lilly and what does Mary aim to achieve in her own future along with If Mary has a competitive nature wouldn't it be contradictory if she hated tests or studying.
I have yet to focus on this subject and rework it but my first thoughts to toward her comments would agree along with establishing Marys need for Lilly by having Marys competitive nature move from studying and school into video games.

The action point we decided upon:
1. The Construction of Wall.E  caste study.
2. Identifying movie from different backgrounds.
3. Review feedback on my Literature review.
4. View "The Triplets of Belleville" against my critical framework.
5. Develop story beats for the current ideas regarding around Lilly and Marys story's
6. Apply Michael Chekhov's formula ( Quality + Action = Emotion) to  Lilly or Marry as a media test.

Saturday, 17 November 2012

Research proposal and Fun examples

Research Proposal

Spent the last few days writing up the quotes into my own words or just quoting in general. I can safely say that the literature review is now at the required length however it could probably do with a few new iterations. The big Issue being picking the write to topics that will address my Aim and Question. Hopefully later this week ill be able to get some feedback on this current draft.
 One of the latest problems current plaguing my mind is still my aim,methodology and introduction. Earlier last night I reached a point of trying to put my thoughts into a  flow diagram mostly because i know that when it comes to explaining my project or what I'm trying to do ill do a terrible job and it will be misinterpreted.

So the Diagram is meant to explain,  That i plan on creating a break down of my character in the form of character analysis/Back-story ideally generating the theoretical personality, thinking and values of my character (Mary and Lilly).  This should then feed into the automatic value response of those character (In other words EMOTION) from there. Using acting and animation methods that actively display traits of emotional/personality have my characters act, react and interact under diffrent contexts, circumstances and atmosphere. Ideally that  emotion and personality will be interpreted or informed into the viewer allowing them to relate to the character analysis.

During my presentation i made mistakes in describing what i was trying to do so i feel now with this all said i should try clarifying it.

I am developing at least two characters Their background story will define who they are and how they would act for example: Mary is never subtle she  moves and performs in an exagerated and extreme level.  There for no matter the circumstance or situation he movements will be broad the only exception of this would be under the tense of sneaking but she will not be practically good and it adding a comedy factor to the situation.
Moving on... This character analysis creates rules at which the character must abide by if she doesn't she looses believe ability and the audience will loose empathy for he. The automatic value response is how she draw conclusions based on her life experience, up bringing ect. (An example will be how do you emotionally respond to situations? its liked back to your "Values" Not mine... YOURS!)

So... So far we have a character who has a personality and is staying true to their character interms of thought. Next is taking those Thoughts and Emotions and Showing them. But how ? Michael Chekhov is an Example. Using his Equations  Quality + Action = Emotion.  The example of this is
Instead of  using Emotion like "Angerly" use the word "forcefully" instead. By doing this you create an intensity... forcefully = a fast action(timing) with power behind it. (an amount of Effort). Action of course is the doing and acting part. So The character Forcefully Slams the desk over "The character Angerly Slams the desk". The question here is which produces a result ? That would require physical experiment. from my own view i prefer Forcefully over Angerly as i directly feel myself adopting the facial expression of anger when i consider slamming my hand against the desk. 

But now from here... Things need to be put into a circumstance/ Context or Atmosphere. Without this last part you don't have personality.  Instead You and Me are just randomly Slamming our desks and anyone watching us will be like WHAT THE HELL !.

Thanks for listening :D
 Edit..
Also How to apply it to animation
Mirrors/ Video recordings or repeatedly slamming that desk to "stay in the moment".
from there you can Adopt the character  the necessary Body postures, Facial expressions, Psychological gesture/ Normal gestures,  The Rhythm and timing along with the power center in which all this attitude comes from.  But of course this part is only in theory and Nancy beiman says that animation cant be based only on theory it a mater of experience and doing.  



Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Meetings, Methodolgy, Research AND DA FUTURE


Over the last week iv mostly been focusing toward the research proposal, Along with re reading and re writing my notes to refresh my head on the topics.

My Current Research question still stands as : How can character personality be created through the action and reaction of a character during an animated short?

I also formed an Aim which i was not sure if it was apply able and which i discussed with lynn.


"The aim of this project is to identify or construct a theory that can convey a character personality through Animation and Acting Techniques." However, What happened to Actions and Reactions ?
  After much stressing and advice, I have came up with The Aim is the exploration of acting theory in character performance to find out if these techniques can enhance the creation of character personality. - Closer But still Not Right ( From my own point of view).

Though the first attempt to the Aim of my project was back from the attempt to construct a theory which is backed by my current research. I had found a template toward the components of personality from Isaac Kerlow. However not all the components applied as my project focuses on character animation.   

  1. External Shape ( The Visual Design of the character)
  2. Silhouette
  3. Internal Structure (The Hierarchy of the skeletal structure -Rig) 
  4. Facial Expressions
  5. Body Poses
  6. Timing
  7. Rhythm
From this I have been reconstructing it so that the research i have been conducting fits into the certain category's because I am focusing on character animation along with using a Education/Source Rig External shape and Internal structure do not directly apply. This has lead me to substitute it with topics which can relate in the same manner. I had also discussed these with Lynn, though we could not conclude anything that the time. However she did mention internal structure wasn't getting as much value as external shape from the example i had shown.


This is my current interpretation of my Critical frame work after our meeting.


1.External Shape – (Acting Theory – Character Performance – Theatrical Acting)
1.Body Posture  - (Responsive, Reflective, Fugitive and Combative)
2.Psychological Gesture  - (What hidden messages are being shown?)
3.Facial Expressions - (Anger, Disgust, Fear, Happiness, Sadness, Surprise, Contempt
4.Eyes - (Blinks – Display of  Thinking -> Conclusion -> Emotion ->  Action)
 
2.Internal structure – (Character Design -  Acting Theory – Method Acting )
1.Character Biography - (The foundation of who the character is.)
2. Thinking
3. Emotion
3.Timing & Rhythm
Context



However there is also topic not included due to lack of knowledge in the area at this time along with an issue of being more selective of the current example.
I believe my current methodology being qualitative, Inductive, Humanities and source research. As there is a heavy emphasis on Interpretation in both my research and the conclusions of both practice and in the project. The project did not start with a theory but is aimed towards creating one which in someways is the critical frame work that is used to identify the personality created.

At this stage i am hoping the next Progress presentation will clarify the value and if i am on the right path in this area. Once this has passed i can then re-evaluate this structure and adapt it accordingly.



Tuesday, 30 October 2012

Animation Mechanics of Motion & Researching Techniques



Animation Mechanics of Motion & The Art of 3D Computer Animation and Effects
Spent the day going through the Two of the books I picked up from the library yesterday. Needless to say they have help broadened my considerations on how to achieve aspects of my project. "Animation Mechanics of Motion"  by Chris Webster has helped clarify why all the acting books(for an animator) I have read mostly emphasize emotion and not as much toward creating personality.  His view on the subject is that in acting they are not focusing toward believability but to express emotion and take the audience on an emotional journey. Though this may seem obvious as acting books focus on emotion this is the first time it has been clearly stated by any of the books I have read. However, saying that their aim was is not to be believable does seem like a slap to the face as I am continuously coming across "The Suspension of Disbelief" which I can now identify in movies when scenes break me out of the immersion of the story which I have linked toward Bullet time and 3D effects.
Another topic that has come up are toward more types of acting, I have previously encountered were Improv (Improvisational Acting/ Thearte),  Method Acting ( thought of the construction of a character from the inside out) and Theatrical Acting (thought of the construction of a character from the outside in).  Chris brings in Physical Acting and Psychological Acting, the way these are talked about makes them seem different from the previous methods as Chris relates physical acting toward pantomime and Charlie Chaplin. While psychological acting has less dynamic movement but more carefully timed and controlled to express emotion and thought using Disney's Bambi(1942) as an example. Though the principle of psychological does seem related or has traits similar to the concepts of Method Acting.

"Bambi" (1942) [After mothers death]
 "The Art of 3D Computer Animation and Effects" by Isaac V. Kerlow  had already made a impression on me when using this book to find out the development of animation and computer technology last year. Though this time around I was focused on character development and personality. The way he writes feel different from other books I had read regarding Animation and Acting. I would say he takes a more simplistic approach which clearly conveys his message. and because of this he has helped identify useful principles that will help me convey character personality. Timing, Tempo, Speed and Rhythm are all terms I have come across before but haven't read too much into them as I already need more practice in timing but the thought of using them to help create personality in quiet inspirational especially when I'm trying to associate songs to the characters I'm currently working on.

Researching Techniques
While continuing to read I'm become more aware toward keeping detailed notes of what I'm reading as book marking the pages isn't useful at all as I have to reread each book to remember what I've read in order to combat this I have started taking Paragraphs or topics directly out of the books and then highlighting the parts which provide useful information and references. This allows me to quickly pull out a quote or be able to paraphrase in the right context.